Why Your Book Cover Matters So Much

Cover of The Judas Cup, a dark thriller by Shaun Ivory

I didn’t need to read the blurb to know I’d be too scared to read the book

Whoever says “you can’t judge a book by its cover” is, frankly, wrong – at least when it comes to books.  After spending quite a few hours this week judging books only by their covers, I’m more convinced than ever of the importance of getting the cover right, if you want to maximise the sales of your books.

What I’ve been doing is neither scientific nor in a professional capacity – but it’s been a real eye-opener all the same.

My first task was to trawl through the stock of my daughter’s  Junior School Library. The books had all been taken off the shelves, which were about to be painted in a gorgeous red gloss. Call us shallow, but we didn’t want to spoil the look of the shiny new shelving with tatty books. It was time to sort and sift.

Some choices were easy. We should ditch any whose title was politically incorrect (e.g. The Life of the American Indian) or whose cover suggested that the content was past its sell-by date (e.g. the guide to modern computing with an Amstrad on the front).

Any volume falling to bits would be binned, no matter how enticing the inside. It was surprising how often the removal of a tatty dustjacket restored a book’s  appeal.

Any book older than a teacher would be deemed out of date. (Apparently schools aspire to a no-older-than-10-years policy, but if enforced it would decimate a lot of school libraries.)

I expected this vetting-by-age process  to be a tiresome process, requiring the  inspection of  small print  inside – and tiring when you’re sitting on school lino surrounded by stacks of books. But I soon realised that all I needed to consider was the general look of the cover – font, image, use of space, etc. It was a totally dependable gauge of age and therefore of the relevance of the content to the young 21st century reader.

Next evening I was again surrounded by books but this time on a different floor – my kitchen’s. I was hemmed in by carrier bags of books donated for sale at a PTA bookstall, fundraising for the school library makeover.  Knowing that they’d sell better if sorted by genre, I was assigning them to labelled laundry baskets for ease of transportation to the Village Hall.

The customer who (flatteringly) assumed that I’d read all the books on my stall was wrong: I was unfamiliar with most of the books and their authors. When I sat down to sort them, I resigned myself to having to read the blurb on the back to discover the genre. But I quickly realised that I didn’t even need to read the title – a glance at the cover told me all I needed to know.

Cover of The Butchered Man by Harriet Smart

No prizes for guessing the genre of this novel

A little later, my laundry baskets looked as if I’d sorted simply by colour: thrillers the colour of bruises, chicklits like sugared almonds, sickly psychedelic sci-fi – and so on.  This is striking evidence of the most important rule of book covers: regardless of the book’s title, the cover’s colour, tone, image and atmosphere  should suggest the book’s genre at a glance. Beware of any publisher whose books all look beautiful but similar. (Even the simple striped Penguin classic cover  was colour-coded.)

Ok, so I’m being simplistic, but there are home truths here too. Cover design is a complex art, and no matter how fabulous your book’s contents, the cover needs to pull its weight in your marketing box of tricks. Perhaps, in his bicentenary year, the last word should go to Charles Dickens:

“There are books of which the backs and covers are by far the best parts.” (Mr Brownlow in Oliver Twist)

Post-script: A little book-weary after these few days of immersion in the printed page, I sat down at my computer to type this post, which I’d already written in my head. Undecided whether the most popular turn of phrase was “you can’t tell a book by its cover” or “you can’t judge a book by its cover”, I consulted Google. Then up popped a much longer article  in The Independent  a couple of years ago, of which the opening sentence is almost identical to mine. The article’s a fascinating readall about book covers and their designers, heralding an exhibition at the Victoria and Albert Museum and a new book about the history of the book cover. I couldn’t wait to see what was on that book’s cover! Click here to read the article.

In my view, the two book covers pictured above are examples of great book jacket design. Both are now available from the online shop of the publisher, SilverWood Books.


3 thoughts on “Why Your Book Cover Matters So Much

  1. I completely agree that cover art is of vital importance! This can’t be stressed enough.

    But–and this is strictly my own opinion–I’ll confess to being put off by the culling process you describe, beginning with the “politically incorrect” title criteria and the example you cite. Okay, so it’s a public school; I guess rationality is optional. But ever since I was a kid, I loved old books. Not only do they smell wonderful–my favorites in the library used to be the “rebounds” with the spiderweb pattern on the inside of the covers–but they open new doors of understanding and give our present-day world greater depth. To deem something “older than the teachers” as irrelevant to the students is nothing short of horrifying. Maybe some of those old books should be given new covers and put back on those shiny new shelves!

    • Hi Yvonne and thanks for such detailed feedback. You make very valid points. I must admit I don’t like having to be politically correct either, but this is what schools have to be these days. Like you, I love old books and have many at home, including books that belonged to my grandparents. My young daughter likes those I had as a child, especially where I coloured in the pictures! Meanwhile at school, we know that the children are more likely to pick up and read shiny, newer books than beaten up old copies – and getting them to use the books is what this whole exercise is about. Your solution of your new covers is a good one – or maybe we ought to have an antiquarian book corner, a museum for old books to treasure. Maybe the children would enjoy that – I’ll put the idea to the teachers! Thanks again for your thoughtful comments!

  2. Pingback: Don’t judge a book by its cover – unless it’s actually a book!! « Since you asked…

Join the conversation - leave a comment!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s